Blog

Every community bank CEO now faces unprecedented challenges. At the same time, powerful new capabilities—Artificial Intelligence (AI) in general, and Agentic AI in particular—offer one of the most viable ways to overcome them.

So why aren't these two realities coming together? Why is the use of Agentic AI still rare in community banks, and what will it take to change that? It starts with acknowledging that successful AI use isn't about the technology. It's about redesigning how your bank operates in a world where intelligence is no longer scarce.

Early adopters in community banking are already reporting benefits such as faster loan decisioning, earlier fraud detection, reduced compliance workloads, and more agile deposit pricing. These improvements are not abstract promises; they reflect practical use cases emerging in banks just like yours.

This proposition builds on themes introduced in Banking AI in 2025 -- A Madness Most Discreet, where we examined how contradictions in banking strategy often go unnoticed until they become unavoidable. This piece is about the choices that need to be made.

First, Consider Your Daily Reality

Do you find it harder than ever to grow Net Interest Margin and Fee Income? Check. Are regulatory mandates becoming more onerous even as your resources remain thin? Check, and check. Are customers comparing you to global fintechs that move in minutes, while you're bound to quarterly ALCO meetings and manual reviews? Is interest rate volatility eroding your margins? Are staffing shortages pushing your teams to the breaking point? Check, check, check. Many banks still rely on processes designed for an era when information was scarce and slow. Today, intelligence is abundant and instant.

And your peers are already proving it. In New York, Dime Community Bank has turned to AI to strengthen its compliance program. In Ohio and Kentucky, HSLC cut loan processing from days to hours, a step soon echoed by Triad Bank in Oklahoma. Security Bank & Trust Co. in Minnesota rolled out an internal AI "copilot" so retail bankers can query policies instantly, reducing escalations to managers. These aren't pilots in labs—they are live, working examples of community banks applying intelligence to the problems you face every day.

The Three-Front Battle Facing Community Bank CEOs

Every bank leader today is juggling three interconnected challenges. First, margin variability driven by rate volatility. ALCO processes and static pricing models struggle to keep pace with today's rapidly changing rate environment, where competitor offerings and customer behavior can shift quickly. Every basis point matters. For a community bank with substantial earning assets, even modest improvements in net interest margin can translate to significant annual revenue—often the difference between hitting earnings targets and missing them.

Second, fee income has stalled. Traditional sources are under pressure while fintechs continue to capture payments, lending, and data-driven services.

Third, compliance demands are rising relentlessly. Community banks face the same BSA/AML, CRA, and fair lending obligations as the largest institutions but with far fewer resources. Compliance officers spend significant portions of their time reviewing false positives, leaving less time for judgment and oversight.

Agentic AI is unique because it does not treat these as isolated issues. It has the potential to bring deposit pricing, customer engagement, and regulatory monitoring into a connected loop, where intelligence is applied continuously rather than in quarterly or annual cycles. When intelligence flows without friction, banks can protect their margins, identify new revenue streams, and reduce the cost of compliance.

How Agentic Banking Works Inside A Community Bank

Agentic Banking is not about dashboards or static reporting. It is about intelligent systems that continuously monitor, analyze and act on data across your institution.

In lending, this means credit decisions informed by real-time borrower cash flows, peer comparisons, property valuations, and external signals, allowing bankers to restructure loans before defaults and move faster on good opportunities.

In compliance, it means systems that learn customer behavior, reduce false positives, detect patterns of fraud or elder abuse, and free compliance staff to focus on judgment and oversight rather than endless alert reviews.

In deposit management, it means pricing that can be adjusted based on competitor rates, customer behavior, and projected cash needs. As a result, rate-sensitive customers are retained with targeted offers, while loyal customers are not repriced unnecessarily.

None of these scenarios replaces people; they amplify them. A lender gains deeper insight, a compliance officer gains more time, and a branch manager gains better recommendations. The result is not a bank that looks more like a fintech, but one that delivers community banking at a higher level.

The Community Bank Advantage

Large banks and fintechs already invest billions in technology and AI. They are shaping customer expectations by making decisions faster and pricing dynamically. But what they cannot replicate is your advantage: trust, local relationships, and community knowledge.

Agentic AI enables you to combine that human strength with real-time intelligence. Imagine an ag lender who knows every farm in three counties, now equipped with commodity market forecasts and weather models. Or how about a business banker who already knows every entrepreneur in town, now supported by early-warning signals of cash flow stress. Or a teller who knows customers by name, now alerted to unusual activity that could signal fraud.

The power of community banking has always been relationships. The opportunity is to add intelligence to those bonds so they are stronger, faster, and more valuable.

How Community Banks Can Start With Agentic AI

Transformation does not require a "big bang" investment. It requires starting with areas where intelligence clearly improves outcomes.

Begin with data that is already available but underused—loan portfolios, transaction flows, deposit patterns. Pilot AI in one area where the benefits are easy to measure, whether that's reducing false positives in BSA/AML, improving deposit retention, or streamlining lending decisions. Scale what works, share results with your board, and expand across the institution.

Banks that start with targeted AI initiatives report meaningful improvements in key metrics—from margin enhancement to compliance efficiency—with benefits often emerging within the first year of implementation. Fee income growth frequently comes not from adding new products, but from better identification of customer needs already present in the data. The key is not the technology itself, but the elimination of bottlenecks that drain staff time and delay decisions.

The Strategic Decision Every Community Bank Faces Now

The past five years have shown how destructive interest rate variability, liquidity shocks, and regulatory scrutiny can be. The next five years will be defined by which banks adapt their operating models to intelligence and which do not. Large institutions and fintechs are already reshaping customer expectations. The risk for community banks is not that they cannot compete, but that they wait too long to change.

Even the ICBA has begun highlighting governance lessons from banks conducting internal audits of where AI is active, including instances where features were turned off in sensitive areas like board portals. The point is that community banks are not waiting on policy alone; they are experimenting, learning, and moving forward.

Your community does not need you to become a technology company. It needs you to remain what you already are—a trusted local institution, but one that is intelligently powered for the realities of 2025 and beyond.

Next Step for Community Bank Leaders

Your bank faces a critical choice: transform with AI or watch competitors pull ahead. Download "The Community Bank Playbook for Agentic AI." Your three biggest challenges – rate variability, stalled fee income, crushing compliance costs – all have AI solutions. Peer banks like HSLC and Dime Community already process loans in hours and slash false positives. This playbook shows you where to focus and how to phase your AI transformation. Stop losing deposits to banks with dynamic pricing. Stop watching commercial customers defect to faster lenders. Get the framework to move from quarterly meetings to real-time intelligence. The 2026 budget window is now.